(CNN) -- After less than 11 hours of deliberation, a jury
Tuesday found Casey Anthony not guilty of first-degree murder and the
other most serious charges against her in the 2008 death of her
2-year-old daughter.
But the jury convicted her on four misdemeanor counts of providing false information to law enforcement officers.
As
the verdict was read, Casey Anthony cried from her seat in the
courtroom, breathing deeply as she looked forward. She then hugged her
defense attorney Jose Baez and other members of her defense team.
Her father, George Anthony, meanwhile, showed no visible reaction from his seat in the back of the courtroom.
Orange
County Chief Judge Belvin Perry Jr. set sentencing at 9 a.m. Thursday
for Casey Anthony. She faces up to a year in jail on each of the charges
of lying to police.
All 12 jurors in the case declined to speak
to the media, court spokeswoman Karen Levey told reporters. "They are
just not interested," she said, adding their response was an
"unequivocal no." Perry has barred the release of their names at this
point, Levey said.
However, one of the five alternate jurors in the case told HLN his opinion on the jury's decision.
"I
agree with their verdict wholeheartedly," said alternate juror Russell
Huekler, who sat through the trial but did not participate in the jury's
deliberations.
"The prosecution did not prove their case," he said. "The big question that was not answered: How did Caylee die?"
That uncertainty was also expressed in a statement released by an attorney for Casey Anthony's family.
"While
the family may never know what happened to Caylee Marie Anthony, they
now have closure for this chapter of their life," said a statement
issued on behalf of Casey Anthony's parents, George and Cindy Anthony,
and her brother, Lee Anthony, by their attorney, Mark Lippman. "They
will now begin the long process of rebuilding their lives."
"There
are no winners in this case," Baez told reporters after the verdict.
"Caylee has passed on far, far too soon." He said his motivation for the
last three years has been seeking justice for Caylee as well as Casey
Anthony.
"Casey did not murder Caylee," he said. "It's that
simple. And today, our system of justice has not dishonored her memory
by a false conviction."
Another defense attorney, J. Cheney
Mason, said he hopes the verdict "is a lesson to those of you having
indulged in media assassination for three years."
"We're
disappointed with the verdict today and surprised, because we know the
facts," Lawson Lamar, state attorney for the 9th District, told
reporters. But, he said, "I never, ever criticize a jury. Theirs is the
task of deciding what to believe."
He praised the job done by
prosecutors, but said proving the case was tough, as Caylee's remains
were skeletal when they were discovered and lacked any chemical
evidence. "This was a dry-bones case," Lamar said. "... The delay in
recovering little Caylee's remains worked to our considerable
disadvantage."
None of the prosecutors who tried the case --
Linda Drane Burdick, Jeff Ashton and Frank George -- spoke at Lamar's
news conference.
The Anthony family statement said, "Despite the
baseless defense chosen by Casey Anthony, the family believes that the
jury made a fair decision based on the evidence presented, the testimony
presented, the scientific information presented and the rules that were
given to them" by the judge.
The Anthonys asked for privacy "to
reflect on this verdict and decide the best way to move forward." They
asked that well-wishers hoping to donate stuffed animals or toys near
their home donate those items instead in Caylee's name to "families in
need, religious centers or any other entity where the toys would be
appreciated."
The Orange County Sheriff's Office will transport
the jurors back to Pinellas County Tuesday night, Levey said. Jury
selection was moved to Pinellas County because of extensive publicity
surrounding the case in the Orlando area, and the jurors have been
sequestered in an Orlando hotel for the trial.
The proceedings
stretched to more than six weeks and featured allegations of sexual
abuse, questions regarding Casey Anthony's competence and various
theories on what happened to Caylee.
Casey Anthony, 25, was
charged with seven counts -- first-degree murder, aggravated child
abuse, aggravated manslaughter of a child and four counts of providing
false information to a law enforcement officer in Caylee's 2008
disappearance and death.
Caylee was last seen June 16, 2008, but
was not reported missing until July 15, 2008, when Casey Anthony's
mother, Cindy Anthony, tracked her daughter down and demanded answers
regarding Caylee's whereabouts.
Prosecutors alleged Casey Anthony used chloroform to render her
daughter unconscious and then duct-taped her mouth and nose to suffocate
her. They alleged that she put the child's body in the trunk of her car
for a few days before disposing of it. Caylee's skeletal remains were
discovered December 11, 2008, by former Orange County meter reader Roy
Kronk.
Casey Anthony's defense attorneys maintained that Caylee
was not murdered at all. They said the child drowned in the Anthony's
above-ground pool on July 16, and that Casey Anthony and her father,
George Anthony, panicked upon finding her there and covered up the
death. George Anthony denied that in his testimony.
The defense
also attempted to cast suspicion on Kronk, the meter reader. Defense
attorneys asserted that he had found Caylee's remains months earlier
than he claimed and that he hid them before placing them where they were
found. He did that, they claimed, just before notifying authorities in
an effort to cash in on the high-profile case.
Kronk denied those
allegations, according to his attorney. He testified on the stand that
after calling police three times in August 2008 to report something
suspicious in the woods, a deputy met him at the scene and "chewed me
out," telling him he was wasting the county's time. He said he dropped
the matter after that until he revisited the scene in December and found
Caylee's skull.
Prosecutors pointed to Casey Anthony's behavior during the 31 days before Caylee was reported missing as evidence of her guilt.
According
to testimony, Casey Anthony was not looking frantically for her missing
child as she later told police. Instead, she moved out of her parents'
home and stayed with her then-boyfriend, Tony Lazzaro. She also got a
tattoo saying "Bella Vita" -- Italian for "beautiful life" -- and went
shopping, witnesses said. She also partied at Orlando nightclubs and
participated in a "hot body" contest at one point, according to
testimony.
Lazzaro and other friends and acquaintances of Casey
Anthony's testified that at no time during that month did she tell
anyone her daughter was missing or ask for help, and she did not seem
anxious or sad. When asked where Caylee was, she told them the child was
with her nanny, a woman named Zenaida Gonzalez. She told her parents
other stories, including that she and Caylee were in Jacksonville
staying with a wealthy suitor, Jeffrey Hopkins.
Eventually confronted by her family, Casey Anthony maintained Gonzalez had kidnapped Caylee.
Authorities
never found the nanny. They found a woman named Zenaida Gonzalez, who
denied ever meeting the Anthonys and later sued for defamation. A man
named Jeffrey Hopkins took the stand and said he was an acquaintance of
Anthony but that the two had never dated. The wealthy suitor and the
nanny were among a host of people Casey Anthony made up, her defense
attorneys acknowledged -- her attorney referred to them as her
"imaginary friends."
Defense attorneys explained Casey Anthony's
behavior in the month before Caylee's disappearance was reported to
police by saying that she had been sexually abused by her father from
the age of 8 and had been taught to conceal her pain. George Anthony
denied that claim in testimony, saying, "I would never do anything like
that to my daughter."
Perry ruled just before closing arguments
began that there was no evidence Casey Anthony had been sexually abused
and prohibited defense attorneys from mentioning it.
The defense
also said Casey Anthony behaved as she did because of her dysfunctional
family. Defense attorney Jose Baez told jurors his client had made some
mistakes and bad decisions, but maintained that was not enough to
convict her of murder.
However, prosecutor Burdick told jurors in
her closing argument, "There's nothing that's wrong with Casey Anthony
that can't be explained in two words: pathological liar."
Casey
Anthony's car -- and the odor emanating from its trunk -- was another
prong of the state's case against her, made up of largely circumstantial
evidence.
On June 27, she abandoned her car at an Orlando
business, saying it had run out of gas, according to testimony. It later
was towed to a wrecker yard, where it remained until July 15, when her
parents, George and Cindy Anthony, received a letter from the tow yard
and went to pick it up.
Numerous witnesses, including a tow yard
employee and George Anthony, said there was a vile smell coming from the
car's trunk. The prosecution alleges -- and a number of witnesses
testified -- that the smell was that of human decomposition.
A
cadaver dog alerted to the possible presence of human decomposition in
the trunk. Arpad Vass, a research scientist at Tennessee's Oak Ridge
National Laboratory, testified that forensic testing of air samples,
carpet, scrapings from the wheel well and a spare tire cover found a
handful of compounds associated with human decomposition.
Vass
said testing showed chloroform present at a "shockingly high" level on a
carpet sample from the trunk. Defense experts who testified, however,
disagreed with Vass' findings and found low amounts of the substance,
which is present in a number of household cleaning products. However,
prosecutor Jeff Ashton pointed out to jurors, none of the experts
disagreed that chloroform was present.
Searches conducted on the
Anthony computer were another focus of the state's case. Computer
experts testified that in March 2008 -- three months before Caylee
disappeared -- someone searched for keywords including "chloroform,"
"how to make chloroform" and "alcohol."
Cindy Anthony took the
stand during the defense's case and testified that she searched for
chloroform, saying that evolved from a search for "chlorophyll" as she
was trying to determine if her dog's habit of eating bamboo plants in
the back yard was making it tired.
Prosecutors introduced work
records showing Cindy Anthony was at work at the time the searches were
conducted. She said she could have left early that day, as she often
took comp time from working overtime.
An attorney for Cindy
Anthony's former employer took the stand as a rebuttal witness. He
brought work records that he said showed that someone using Cindy
Anthony's credentials was logged in and using a desktop computer at her
office on the days when those searches were done on her family's home
computer.
On the defense's contention that Caylee drowned in the
Anthony pool, Cindy Anthony testified that Caylee was able to climb into
the pool on her own. But she said the toddler could not have put on the
pool's removable ladder or opened gates leading to the area. Baez told
jurors in his closing argument that Cindy Anthony may have left the
ladder up the night before, when she and Caylee went swimming, although
she testified she did not.
Jurors heard hours of forensic testimony, receiving crash courses in DNA, hair analysis and chemistry, among others.
Experts
testified that a hair found in Casey Anthony's trunk had a band that
suggested it was from a decomposing body. The hair was similar to
Caylee's, according to forensic experts, but could not absolutely be
proved to be hers.
The trial was abruptly halted on Saturday,
June 25 -- Perry said on June 27 that Casey Anthony had been examined by
two psychologists and a psychiatrist following a defense motion
questioning whether she was competent to proceed.
The defense
called a woman to the stand who volunteered in the search for Caylee.
Krystal Holloway testified that she and George Anthony had an affair.
Holloway said that he once told her what happened to Caylee was "an
accident that snowballed out of control." George Anthony denied the
affair, and prosecutors used Holloway's statement to police to say she
was taking George Anthony's comment out of context. According to the
statement, Holloway told authorities George Anthony said he believed
Caylee's death stemmed from an accident and that Casey Anthony may have
covered it up somehow.
Throughout the trial, the pain experienced
by Casey Anthony's family was evident. Both her father and mother
sobbed on the stand at times recalling their granddaughter. George
Anthony also cried as he testified about his January 2009 suicide
attempt, which came shortly after Caylee's remains were identified.
Jurors
heard testimony about items found with Caylee's remains. A Winnie the
Pooh blanket matched the one found in the little girl's room at the
Anthony home. The laundry bag that prosecutor Ashton told jurors served
as Caylee's coffin was one of a matching set -- the other was found at
the home. And all that remained of the little girl's T-shirt, saying
"Big Trouble Comes in Small Packages," were some letters and the
stitching around the collar.
Prosecutors pointed out in closing arguments that only Casey Anthony had access to all the items of evidence.