Vasanthakumar attacked his former Hindraf comrades in a one-hour tirade. — Picture by Jack Ooi
KLANG, Nov 26 — In accepting former Hindraf treasurer K. Vasanthakumar as a leading member, the PKR may have invited in a quarrelsome and difficult person unlikely to contribute to unity among the Indian members of the multi-ethnic party.
An immediate indicator of the turbulent times ahead was the announcement Vasanthakumar made at the close of the gathering in Klang to commemorate the 2nd anniversary of the Nov 25, 2007 Hindraf protest — that his camp had "sacked" P. Waythamoorthy as chairman of Hindraf.
“He was sacked because he is incompetent and causing confusion,” said Vasanthakumar, who was accused of being a police agent by Waythamoorthy and his brother P. Uthayakumar.
His act took many Pakatan Rakyat leaders by surprise because the coalition's national co-ordinator Datuk Zaid Ibrahim had recently held cordial discussions with Waythamoorthy.
“We are wooing him and hope to form an alliance with him ahead of the next general election,” said a senior PR leader, expressing worry over Vasanthakumar’s unbridled anger and hostility towards Waythamoorthy and his brother Uthayakumar, who is head of the yet-to-be-registered Human Rights Party Malaysia.
“Have we bought ourselves a uncontrollable wild horse in Vasanthakumar?,” the leader wondered.
Vasanthakumar, who has denied the charges, attacked the brothers in a one-hour tirade yesterday, accusing them of not accounting for large sums of money, misleading and failing the Indian community and for not pursuing a billion ringgit lawsuit in London against the British government for “abandoning” Indians to exploitation in Malaysia.
He named names, amounts and bank accounts he, as treasurer of Hindraf, had deposited the money into and questioned why the cash had not been accounted for.
He also attacked in unvarnished terms former Hindraf national co-coordinator R.S. Thanenthiran, who is founder president of the new Makkal Shakti Party, as a traitor and Umno stooge.
Screaming in a high-pitched voice, he declared that “Umno is the permanent enemy of Hindraf” to muted response from the crowd gathered in Klang last night.
The audience appeared shocked by his anger.
Significantly, a good part of the former Hindraf leadership skipped the function except for fellow ISA detainee Ganapathy Rao who also spoke at the function but minus the ranting.
Others Hindraf leaders close to Uthayakumar, who held rival events marking the day like DAP leaders Manoharan Malayalam and Kapar MP S. Manicavasagam, also skipped the function that was opened by PR supremo Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim.
Anwar arrived early, gave a short speech acknowledging and thanking Indian contributions toward PR’s performance in Election 2008.
He said there were shortcomings but PR was doing its best to resolve Indian.
DAP leader and Penang Deputy Chief Minister P. Ramasamy expanded on the themes touched by Vasanthakumar by calling Waythamoorthy, but without specifically naming him, a traitor and coward, for staying abroad while “our Hindraf” leaders suffered under the ISA.
Ramasamy also attacked Thanenthiran and other Hindraf leaders as traitors and compared them to historical Tamil figures like Ettapan, who allegedly betrayed the Tamil ruler Veerapandiya Kattabomban to the British invaders.
He said that if PR captured Putrajaya, Hindraf would be given legal recognition, all partially-aided Tamil schools would be converted into fully-aided Tamil schools, Tamil education would continue from “primary level right up to the university” and an Indian would be named Deputy Prime Minister.
Neither the brothers nor Thanenthiran and their supporters are expected to stay quiet after last night's attacks on them.
The event had been touted as a night for reconciliation with Anwar reconnecting with Hindraf.
But instead after Anwar left for another engagement, the daggers came out and the night ended with more recriminations than reconciliation.
“We the people are united in our grievances but they our leaders are divided and ready to kill each other,” said retired rubber tapper Palanisamy Perumal, 65, as he boarded the bus for the long, overnight journey back to his estate in Kedah.
“I am disappointed,” he said with a sad smile.************
Two years on, Hindraf a spent force
Hindraf supporters stage a hunger strike in front of KLCC in Kuala Lumpur this morning to mark the second anniversary of the massive Hindraf protest in the city. — Picture by Jack Ooi
KUALA LUMPUR, Nov 25 — Two years ago on this day in 2007 Hindraf organised a protest that saw thousands of working-class Indians take to the streets here, but little remains of its influence today.
The way the rival Hindraf factions are marking the 2nd anniversary of the protest today is indicative of the bleak future of the movement founded by brothers P. Waythamoorthy and Uthayakumar, both lawyers.
While several of the original six Hindraf leaders, including the five who were held under the ISA, are apathetic, many of its members have moved on by joining political parties like the DAP or PKR.
Leaders like Uthayakumar and the former national co-ordinator R.S. Thanenthiran have set up their own political parties and others like former Hindraf treasurer Vasantha Kumar have set up their own NGOs.
All are one way or the other using the Hindraf or Makkal Sakthi name to keep the Indian protest fire alive and hope to ride the wave to political victory in the next general election.
Vasantha Kumar is organising a large-scale Hindraf 2nd anniversary gathering in Klang tonight where he is also expected to formally join the PKR.
A VVIP, believed to be PKR supremo Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, is expected to attend, a key organiser of the function told The Malaysian Insider.
He said however that Anwar’s attendance would depend on the size of the crowd and whether the police permit is cancelled at the last minute.
“We are keeping our fingers crossed,” said the organiser who declined to be named.
“Police had shut down a gathering in Johor last week just before Anwar spoke… the same can happen here.”
“We expect at least 5,000 people,” he said.
Text messages are also circulating claiming that Uthayakumar would attend Vasantha Kumar's rally but Uthayakumar when contacted denied he would attend.
"We are marking the Hindraf anniversary in a grand way with protests, fast, prayers and other events," he said.
Uthayakumar and Vasantha Kumar were once close but have since fallen out, accusing each other of pilfering money or working for the police.
A rival Hindraf gathering is also being organised in Klang and probably targeted to draw the crowd away from Vasantha Kumar’s event.
Hindraf insiders say the rival event is organised by supporters of Uthayakumar, who is pro-tem president of the Human Rights Party Malaysia.
Uthayakumar's aides say it is all right for Hindraf supporters to organise functions to mark Hindraf’s 2nd anniversary anywhere in the country.
"We have a strong support base in Klang," the aide said, declining to comment on Vasantha Kumar's rally. "He has betrayed the Hindraf aims and mission."
Vasantha Kumar could not be reached for comment.
To mark the day Uthayakumar is organising several events under the title of “neo-democratic revolution” against the “totalitarian government led by Umno.”
The event involves a protest fast by 18 supporters outside KLCC, a memorandum to Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak and prayers at “more than 100 locations” in the country followed by a Ruthra Yagam or fire ritual prayers at the Agora Veerabathrar Sanggili Karuppar temple at 17½ mile Kampung. Benggali, Rawang, on Nov 29.
Unlike 2007, Hindraf is increasingly giving up on direct political action and relying more on religion through fasting and prayers as tools to organise and win over the Indian working class.
At the other end of the spectrum is the newly-formed pro-Barisan Nasional Makkal Sakthi party which is well funded. It is using a direct house-to-house approach to meet and persuade Indians to join up and support BN.
Its weapon of persuasion is the measures taken by the government under Najib to resolve longstanding woes like getting citizenship and identity cards.
"We are finally recognised and our demands are gradually met... this is the time for us to reap the benefits for our community," said a state leader of the Makkal Sakthi Party. "Pakatan promised but failed to deliver, Barisan is delivering without even promising."
Makkal Sakthi party is particularly active in Perak where the balance of power between Pakatan Rakyat and BN is almost even and Indian voters can make or break either coalition.
The MIC too is rebuilding itself from defeat and with long-time president Datuk Seri S. Samy Vellu expected to exit by May 2010; the party will have a new leader and probably a new mission — to reunite Indians under its wings.
With its ranks woefully split and challenged from outside by new players and a re-energised MIC, Hindraf is fast losing its influence.
It also lacks a creative and imaginative leadership to pull it out of the rut and turn it into a united and national political force.More Pictures
No comments:
Post a Comment