Umno can choose to work with PAS on hudud as the Islamic party delivers them more seats than many BN component parties combined.
COMMENT
PAS has until June to table its private member’s bills in parliament to permit the Kelantan state government to implement hudud, but political parties from both divides are already agitated.
Pakatan Rakyat for one is definitely worried that the Barisan Alternatif episode in 2001 would recur.
Back then, DAP had to break ties with PAS due to the Islamic party’s insistence to push its Islamic agenda.
The ups and downs in politics saw DAP and PAS reeling back to the same table only after the opposition scored a breakthrough to deny BN its two-third majority in the 2008 general election.
Since then, with the growing number of progressive leaders in PAS and political pragmatism, PAS has toned down its Islamic appeal. But hudud remains a thorn in Pakatan’s flesh.
But the decisive moment will arrive in the coming months. Should PAS be able to table its bill and get it passed in parliament, DAP would have no choice but turn its back on PAS.
The fallout between the two will spell an end of Pakatan Rakyat coalition if the bill is passed. Nevertheless till then it is still safe.
Umno holds the trump card
This issue could bring a similar disaster to BN too.
Of late, Umno ministers like Jamil Khir Baharom and Razali Ibrahim have indicated that they are willing to work with PAS to allow Kelantan to impose hudud.
Going by the words of Razali, the deputy minister in Prime Minister Department, PAS can even count on all Umno lawmakers “to vote for the bill”.
Even progressive Umno leaders such as Tengku Razaleigh Hamzah and Shahrir Samad said they are open to PAS tabling the bill.
Umno’s statement revealed a stark reality in today’s politics. First, Muslim lawmakers are duty bound by religion to support hudud, regardless which divide they are in.
More importantly, Umno can forsake most of its BN colleagues in place for PAS and still retain federal power.
Umno controls 88 seats in Parliament, whereas PAS has 21. With the help of Sarawak-based Parti Pesaka Bumiputera Bersatu (PBB), which holds 14 seats, Umno can still form the federal government and have representatives all over the country.
On the contrary, other BN component parties are pretty much dependent on Umno to cling on to power.
MCA, MIC, Gerakan, Parti Bersatu Sabah and the other East Malaysia parties combined command only 31 seats. Even if they were to join forces with DAP and PKR they will still fall short of coming into power (99 seats).
As such Umno holds the superior bargaining power. It can create a major paradigm shift in politics in Malaysia if it decides so.
MCA, Gerakan dousing the fire
MCA, meanwhile hopes that Umno would see through PAS’ tactics and stands its ground.
“PAS’ position is very clear, it only wants to trap Umno (with the bill). All this while they have been calling Umno infidel, now they suddenly turn to Umno for favour as if they are so sincere,” said MCA deputy president Wee Ka Siong.
PAS wants to look good among the traditional Malays, he told FMT, while DAP is opposing it because it cannot afford to lose its Chinese votes.
As such, he urged Umno to be smart and distance itself from the bill since it is mooted by the opposition.
“This is entirely a Pakatan internal affair. They cannot sort it out among themselves, let them fight and we should just watch at the side.
“I hope Umno will stick to the Federal Constitution, this was agreed upon by all parties since Independence,” he said.
Agreeing with Wee, Gerakan president Mah Siew Keong said his party would try its level best to convince Umno on the problems of hudud laws, should the bill be heard in parliament.
“A parallel legal system for Muslims will create a lot of conflicts in a multi-religious country like Malaysia, for example, in criminal cases involving Muslims and non-Muslims,” he said.
Both MCA and Gerakan have said their MPs would definitely vote against the bill.
The bill could have far-reaching impact on the nation, changing the way justice is delivered as well as the political landscape.
Anyways, it could also end up like many other private member’s bill which never saw the light of day in parliament.
Leven Woon is a FMT team member.
COMMENT
Pakatan Rakyat for one is definitely worried that the Barisan Alternatif episode in 2001 would recur.
Back then, DAP had to break ties with PAS due to the Islamic party’s insistence to push its Islamic agenda.
The ups and downs in politics saw DAP and PAS reeling back to the same table only after the opposition scored a breakthrough to deny BN its two-third majority in the 2008 general election.
Since then, with the growing number of progressive leaders in PAS and political pragmatism, PAS has toned down its Islamic appeal. But hudud remains a thorn in Pakatan’s flesh.
But the decisive moment will arrive in the coming months. Should PAS be able to table its bill and get it passed in parliament, DAP would have no choice but turn its back on PAS.
The fallout between the two will spell an end of Pakatan Rakyat coalition if the bill is passed. Nevertheless till then it is still safe.
Umno holds the trump card
This issue could bring a similar disaster to BN too.
Of late, Umno ministers like Jamil Khir Baharom and Razali Ibrahim have indicated that they are willing to work with PAS to allow Kelantan to impose hudud.
Going by the words of Razali, the deputy minister in Prime Minister Department, PAS can even count on all Umno lawmakers “to vote for the bill”.
Even progressive Umno leaders such as Tengku Razaleigh Hamzah and Shahrir Samad said they are open to PAS tabling the bill.
Umno’s statement revealed a stark reality in today’s politics. First, Muslim lawmakers are duty bound by religion to support hudud, regardless which divide they are in.
More importantly, Umno can forsake most of its BN colleagues in place for PAS and still retain federal power.
Umno controls 88 seats in Parliament, whereas PAS has 21. With the help of Sarawak-based Parti Pesaka Bumiputera Bersatu (PBB), which holds 14 seats, Umno can still form the federal government and have representatives all over the country.
On the contrary, other BN component parties are pretty much dependent on Umno to cling on to power.
MCA, MIC, Gerakan, Parti Bersatu Sabah and the other East Malaysia parties combined command only 31 seats. Even if they were to join forces with DAP and PKR they will still fall short of coming into power (99 seats).
As such Umno holds the superior bargaining power. It can create a major paradigm shift in politics in Malaysia if it decides so.
MCA, Gerakan dousing the fire
MCA, meanwhile hopes that Umno would see through PAS’ tactics and stands its ground.
“PAS’ position is very clear, it only wants to trap Umno (with the bill). All this while they have been calling Umno infidel, now they suddenly turn to Umno for favour as if they are so sincere,” said MCA deputy president Wee Ka Siong.
PAS wants to look good among the traditional Malays, he told FMT, while DAP is opposing it because it cannot afford to lose its Chinese votes.
As such, he urged Umno to be smart and distance itself from the bill since it is mooted by the opposition.
“This is entirely a Pakatan internal affair. They cannot sort it out among themselves, let them fight and we should just watch at the side.
“I hope Umno will stick to the Federal Constitution, this was agreed upon by all parties since Independence,” he said.
Agreeing with Wee, Gerakan president Mah Siew Keong said his party would try its level best to convince Umno on the problems of hudud laws, should the bill be heard in parliament.
“A parallel legal system for Muslims will create a lot of conflicts in a multi-religious country like Malaysia, for example, in criminal cases involving Muslims and non-Muslims,” he said.
Both MCA and Gerakan have said their MPs would definitely vote against the bill.
The bill could have far-reaching impact on the nation, changing the way justice is delivered as well as the political landscape.
Anyways, it could also end up like many other private member’s bill which never saw the light of day in parliament.
Leven Woon is a FMT team member.
No comments:
Post a Comment