Share |

Monday, 21 December 2009

Pakatan's Common Platform Looks Good But Pledges Are Just Talk For Now

Pakatan has been criticized for not making its governance model comprehensive and transparent. This has resulted in the newly minted coalition being called a 'fly-by-night' operation.

The coalition has responded quite positively to the criticism and has unveiled for the first time its stand on several important key areas at their maiden convention. However, some highly anticipated issues such as local council election, Freedom of Information Act, and the status of secular Malaysia are left undefined.

Some good policy announcements include the much needed decentralisation of economy planning and management at the state government level. This move will allow state governments more control over their own economy and investment planning and promotion. Malaysia's economic development is long hampered by inefficient and ineffective over centralisation at the federal government.

Economic Planning Unit and several ministries responsible for socio-economic development have done very little to push up the efficiency, vibrancy and productivity of our economic sectors. Over centralisation also breeds corruption. Overlap in decision making between ministries has resulted in unnecessary bureaucracy.

The move to decentralise the economy is a plus point for the Pakatan.

The coalition has promised to implement the Equal Opportunity Act and to provide help and assistance based on need not race. This is a good move and will help to retain capable people in the country. Affirmative action based on race is the sole main push factor for brain drain in the country.

Rightly, the coalition has decided to empower the parliament, which is still a rubber stamp of the ruling executives, by making GLCs and public institutions accountable to the august house. The outcome will be positive for all parliamentarians. If needed, they can form special committees to probe and enquire about certain policy decisions taken by these GLCs and institutions. The move will allow for better parliamentary transparency.

Parliamentarians will have to be more educated and informed on issues and policies Malaysia's main problem is unqualified and low value added people are being voted into parliament while the capable ones are staying away from politics.

It is comforting to know that the coalition has pledged to implement the IPCMC, Judicial Appointment Commission and help to address the overlap between civil and syariah law. The leaders must also pledge to stay away from interfering with the jurisdiction and work of these independent institutions in the future. The political nexus between political parties and these institutions must be severed permanently.

Other key areas:

Healthcare - Establishing a National Heath Commission to improve public healthcare.

Women - Ensuring 30 percent representation at the government's decision-making level.

Police - Establishing the Independent Police Complaints and Misconduct Commission.

Culture - Liberalising restriction on performances by artistes. (Personally, I am glad this is included in the policy statement. Currently, the whole permit application process is riddled with redtape and corruption)

Language - Promoting Bahasa Malaysia as the regional lingua franca but protecting mother tongue languages.

Labour - Minimum wage policy.

Social security - Establishing a National Retrenchment Fund.

Elections - Redelineation of electoral boundaries to fulfil concept of 'one person, one vote'.

Public transport - Study the possibility of buying back North-South Highway and renegotiating highway concessions to reduce toll prices.

Media - Amending the Printing Presses and Publishing Act to ensure media freedom.

This is a positive step forward for Pakatan. I hope more of us will keep a copy of their pledges and make sure that Pakatan leaders walk the talk.

Unfortunately, there is no indication of further democratisation through local council election. This is a grey area. Some had defended Pakatan's lack of action by claiming that this can only be implemented by the federal government.

This is not necessarily true. The state government should study the legal and constitutional provision for a local council election. Local councils are under the control of state government.

Hence, I support the call of both Haris Ibrahim and Wong Chin Huat for an immediate action to allow real democratisation to happen. Pakatan's pledges are just pledges. Most of these pledges cannot be implemented unless they win federal power. We know what to believe and take home from these pledges.

What's more important is still what the Pakatan led state governments can do within their own jurisdiction. It is time for them to push the envelope and to test the legal provision on local council election.

They can still be outperformed by Najib's administration. BN can make and implement these pledges immediately. At the end, voters will still support a coalition which can make things happen and enhance their living standards. - http://khookaypeng.blogspot.com/2009/12/pakatans-common-platform-looks-good.html

1 comment:

Brian Barker said...

I think that the World needs a lingua franca as well. As a native English speaker, I would prefer Esperanto :)

Your readers may be interested in http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g2LPVcsL2k0 Dr Kvasnak teaches English at Florida Atlantic University.

A glimpse of Esperanto can be seen at http://www.lernu.net